Figure Computed mo del predictions for the time ev olution of the ratio of pro duction to dissipation P in homogeneous shear o w corresp onding to the initial conditions b b S K a IP Mo del b Shih Lumley Mo del and c the FL T Mo del Figure Time ev olution of the normal Reynolds stress in homogeneous shear o w Comparison of computed results for the FL T Mo del corresp onding to b b S K with the Rapid Distortion Theory RDT solution LIST OF FIGURES Figure Sc hematic of p ossible time ev olutions of the in v arian t function F passing through the realizabilit y b oundary F Figure The t w o principal branc hes of the solution to the di eren tial equation F F with the initial condition F q Figure Numerical solution to the di eren tial equation F jF j with the initial condi tion F Figure Computed phase space tra jectories in homogeneous shear o w for the initial conditions b b S K a Shih Lumley Mo del and b the IP Mo del of Launder and co w ork ers Figure Mo del predictions for the time ev olution of the Reynolds stress anisotropies in homogeneous shear o w corresp onding to the initial conditions b b S K a F and b b Figure Computed results for homogeneous shear o w corresp onding to the initial con ditions b b S K a phase space tra jectories of the Shih Lumley Mo del b time ev olution of F and c time ev olution of b Figure Computed phase space tra jectories for homogeneous shear o w corresp onding to the initial conditions b b S K a the Shih Lumley Mo del and b the IP Mo del of Launder and co w ork ers Figure Computed phase space tra jectories for homogeneous shear o w corresp onding to the initial conditions b b b S K a the IP Mo del and b the FL T Mo del of Launder and co w ork ers Figure Mo del predictions for the time ev olution of the Reynolds stress anisotropies in homogeneous shear o w corresp onding to the initial conditions b b b and S K a F and b b Figure Computed phase space tra jectories of the FL T Mo del in homogeneous shear o w corresp onding to the initial conditions b b S K Sp eziale C G Gatski T B and Sark ar S On T esting Mo dels for the Pressure Strain Correlation of T urbulence using Direct Sim ulations Phys Fluids A T a v oularis S and Corrsin S Exp erimen ts in Nearly Homogeneous T urbulen t Shear Flo w with a Uniform Mean T emp erature Gradien t P art I J Fluid Me ch T a v oularis S and Karnik U F urther Exp erimen ts on the Ev olution of T urbulen t Stresses and Scales in Uniformly Sheared T urbulence J Fluid Me ch Zeman O and Lumley J L Mo deling Buo y ancy Driv en Mixed La y ers J A tmos Sci Orszag S A Analytical Theories of T urbulence J Fluid Me ch Orszag S A Statistical Theories of T urbulence in Fluid Dynamics L es Houche Gordon and Breac h P op e S B Pdf Metho ds for T urbulen t Reactiv e Flo ws Pr o g Ener gy Combust Sci P op e S B On the Relationship Bet w een Sto c hastic Lagrangian Mo dels of T urbulence and Second Momen t Closures Phys Fluids A to app ear Reynolds W C F undamen tals of T urbulence for T urbulence Mo deling and Sim u lation in L e ctur e Notes for V on Karman Institute A GARD L e ct Ser No pp NA TO Rogers M M Moin P and Reynolds W C The Structure and Mo deling of the Hydro dynamic and P assiv e Scalar Fields in Homogeneous T urbulen t Shear Flo w Stanfor d University T e chnic al R ep ort TF Sark ar S and Sp eziale C G A Simple Nonlinear Mo del for the Return to Isotrop y in T urbulence Phys Fluids A Sc h umann U Realizabilit y of Reynolds Stress T urbulence Mo dels Phys Fluids Shih T H and Lumley J L Mo deling of Pressure Correlation T erms in Reynolds Stress and Scalar Flux Equations Cornel l University T e chnic al R ep ort FD A Shih T H and Lumley J L Second Order Mo deling of Boundary F ree T urbulen t Shear Flo ws AIAA J Shih T H and Lumley J L Critical Comparison of Second Order Closures with Direct Numerical Sim ulations of Homogeneous T urbulence AIAA J Sp eziale C G Discussion of T urbulence Mo deling Presen t and F uture in L e ct Notes in Physics ed J L Lumley pp Springer V erlag Sp eziale C G Analytical Metho ds for the Dev elopmen t of Reynolds Stress Closures in T urbulence A nn R ev Fluid Me ch Sp eziale C G Gatski T B and Mac Giolla Mh uiris N A Critical Comparison of T urbulence Mo dels for Homogeneous Shear Flo ws in a Rotating F rame Phys Fluids A REFERENCES Abid R and Sp eziale C G Predicting Equilibrium States with Reynolds Stress Closures in Channel Flo w and Homogeneous Shear Flo w Phys Fluids A Deardor J W The Use of Subgrid T ransp ort Equations in a Three Dimensional Mo del of A tmospheric T urbulence ASME J Fluids Eng Durbin P A and Sp eziale C G Realizabilit y of Second Momen t Closure via Sto c hastic Analysis CTR Manuscript NASA Ames Stanford Cen ter for T ur bulence Researc h F u S Launder B E and Tselepidakis D P Accommo dating the E ects of High Strain Rates in Mo deling the Pressure Strain Correlation UMIST T e chnic al R ep ort TFD Gibson M M and Launder B E Ground E ects on Pressure Fluctuations in the A tmospheric Boundary La y er J Fluid Me ch Goldstein H Classic al Me chanics nd ed Addison W esley Ha w orth D C and P op e S B A Generalized Langevin Mo del for T urbulen t Flo ws Phys Fluids Hinze J O T urbulenc e nd ed McGra w Hill Kraic hnan R H Dynamics of Nonlinear Sto c hastic Systems J Math Phys Launder B E Reece G J and Ro di W Progress on the Dev elopmen t of a Reynolds Stress T urbulence Closure J Fluid Me ch Lee M J Kim J and Moin P Structure of T urbulence at High Shear Rate J Fluid Me ch Lumley J L Computational Mo deling of T urbulen t Flo ws A dv Appl Me ch Lumley J L T urbulence Mo deling ASME J Appl Me ch Mellor G L and Herring H J A Surv ey of Mean T urbulen t Field Closure Mo dels AIAA J C C B p p p C I I F F C I I F B IP Mo del C b C P P B ij ij ij ij C C B where C C B v v j i P B ij ik j k x x k k v i P B ij x j APPENDIX B The detailed form of the turbulence mo dels considered in the pap er are as follo ws Shih Lumley Mo del C b K S K b S b S ij ij ij ik j k j k ik b S K b b k l k l ij ik j k j k ik B K b b S b b S b S b il lm j m j l lm im ik k l lj b S b K b b b b k l k l ij il lm j m j l lm im q C C exp Re l n I I B t v v v v i j i j S B ij ij x x x x j i j i q q F C exp Re f Re l n I I I I I g B t t F I I I I I B I I b b I I I b b b B ij ij ij j k k i K Re B t F B F u L aunder Tselepidakis Mo del C b C b b b b ij ij ik k j k l k l ij K S K b S b S b S ij ik j k j k ik k l k l ij K b b K b b S ik j k j k ik ik k l j l B b b S b S b b S b j k k l il ik k l lj k l k l ij K b b b b K I I b ik k l j l j k k l il ik j k b b b b b b b j k ik ik k l lm mj j k k l lm mi Cap elli s iden tit y giv en b y the determinan t e e A can b e applied to the fourth term on the righ t hand side of A After simplifying w e arriv e at the nal result T T e T e T e T A e T T T T T T T APPENDIX A Relativ e to a co ordinate system with unit v ectors that is undergoing a time dep enden t rotation an y symmetri c tensor T tak es the form T T A Hence the rst time deriv ativ e is giv en b y T T T T A since t It is w ell kno wn that for an y unit v ector rotating with angular v elo cit y w e ha v e cf Goldstein A e Hence T T e T e T A or equiv alen tly T T e T e T A The second time deriv ativ e is giv en b y T T T T T T T A Since A e w e ha v e T T e T e T e e T e T A e T T T T where Finally some commen ts are w arran ted concerning the imp ortan t implications that these results ha v e for turbulence mo deling The notion that realizabilit y constrain ts can b e used to calibrate a second order closure mo del app ears no w to b e fundamen tally unsound The pro cess of ensuring realizabilit y is decidedly non unique There is no apparen t w a y to satisfy the strong form of realizabilit y in the existing hierarc h y of second order closures and there are an in nit y of w a ys in whic h the w eak form of realizabilit y can b e implem en te d This brings us to the more fundamen tal question Wh y is there suc h an obsession with realizabilit y constrain ts in second order closure mo deling It is a w ell established result that the standard form of the mo deled dissipation rate equation guaran tees limited realizabilit y namely non negativ e v alues for the turbulen t kinetic energy and dissipation rate in homogeneous turbulence see Sp eziale F urthermore so long as the xed p oin ts of the mo del are realizable and su cien tly strong attractors at w orst there will b e a short tr ansient where one or t w o comp onen ts of the turbulen t kinetic energy b ecome negativ e This in general do es not ha v e to b e computationally fatal particularly if for inhomogeneous o ws the turbulen t di usion terms are mo deled with isotropic gradien t transp ort mo dels suc h as those in tro duced b y Mellor and Herring n umerical instabilities generally arise from negativ e di usivities T ypically the short transien ts where realizabilit y violations o ccur are in turbulen t o ws that are so far from equilibrium that simple one p oin t closures cannot b e exp ected to apply in the rst place In an e ort to a v oid short liv ed regimes where the solution can b ecome unrealizable mo dels dev elop ed based on realizabilit y constrain ts ha v e b een complicated substan tially leading to highly ill b eha v ed solutions that ha v e no greater predictiv e capabilities than those of the simpler mo dels near the limits of realizable turbulence In fact the higher degree nonlinearities in tro duced to satisfy realizabilit y often render a mo del ill b eha v ed to the p oin t where the solution is con taminated b y large amplitude oscillations for long durations of time This is extremely un wise It w ould b e far preferable to in tro duce mathematical devices to a v oid computationally dangerous unrealizable b eha vior in turbulen t o ws that are far from equilibrium without compromising the near equilibrium predictions of a mo del A simple mathematical means for making an y existing second order closure mo del realizable in this fashion based on a sto c hastic analysis is the sub ject of a companion pap er Durbin and Sp eziale Ac kno wledgemen ts The authors w ould lik e to thank Prof N Fitzmaurice Case W estern Reserv e Univ ersit y for some helpful discussions The second author RA ac kno wledges the supp ort of NASA Langley Researc h Cen ter through a con tract to High T ec hnology Corp oration their mo del con taining F are made single v alued in a ph ysically consisten t fashion a simpli cation whic h in v ariably leads to a violation of the crucial p ositiv e second deriv ativ e constrain t whic h requires that when v anishes Since the Shih Lumley mo del w as calibrated largely based on what no w app ear to b e questionable realizabilit y considerations it b ecomes more understandable wh y the mo del do es not p erform w ell in basic b enc hmark turbulen t o ws as recen tly sho wn b y Sp eziale Gatski and Sark ar and Abid and Sp eziale The cen trifugal acceleration generated b y rotations of the principal axes of the Reynolds stress tensor can render singular at the limits of one comp onen t turbulence and axisymmetri c t w o comp onen t turbulence the endp oin ts A and B of the t w o comp onen t line of the Lumley anisotrop y in v arian t map sho wn in Figure a This mak es it imp ossible to guaran tee the satisfaction of the p ositiv e second deriv ativ e constrain t in existing second order closure mo dels a de ciency that can lead to realizabilit y violations It th us app ears to b e imp ossible to identic al ly satisfy the strong form of realizabilit y in the curren t generation of second order closures The only w a y to unequiv o cally guaran tee realizabilit y in the curren t generation of second order closures is via the w eak form of realizabilit y where access to one or t w o comp onen t states of turbulence is a v oided The w eak form of realizabilit y as rst prop osed b y P op e do es indeed guaran tee non negativ e comp onen t energies in arbitrary homogeneous turbulen t o ws Ho w ev er there is an asso ciated Sc h w arz inequalit y inconsistency with this form of w eak realizabilit y that led us to prop ose an alternativ e form whic h allo ws mo del predictions to come arbitrarily close to one and t w o comp onen t states In terestingly enough the F u Launder and Tselepidakis FL T mo del satis es this alternativ e form of w eak realizabilit y and th us unlik e the Shih Lumley mo del it guaran tees p ositiv e comp onen t energies in general homogeneous turbulen t o ws In an attempt to satisfy the strong form of realizabilit y b oth the Shih Lumley and FL T mo dels in tro duce higher degree nonlinearities in the mo deling of the rapid pressure strain correlation It w as demonstrated in computations of homogeneous shear o w that these higher order terms cause the mo dels to b ecome highly ill b eha v ed near one or t w o comp onen t states of turbulence where they generate large amplitude oscillations that are unph ysical Older mo dels suc h as the Launder Reece and Ro di and IP mo dels that are linear do not ha v e this problem It m ust b e remem b ered that the rapid pressure strain correlation is b y its de nition linear in the energy sp ectrum tensor a prop ert y that suc h nonlinear mo dels do not p ossess IP FL T and Shih Lumley mo dels see Figures a c The IP mo del predicts a P that p eaks at S t and then monotonically approac hes its equilibrium v alue of P see Figure a While w e ha v e no con dence in the quan titativ e accuracy of these results the crucial p oin t is that the IP mo del predicts a strictly non ne gative turbulence pro duction On the other hand the Shih Lumley and FL T mo dels predict that P undergo es large amplitude oscillations b et w een p ositiv e and negativ e v alues see Figures b c W e b eliev e that these results are highly unph ysical there is no apparen t ph ysical mec hanism b y whic h a homogeneous shear o w can pro duce a negativ e turbulence pro duction giv en that it is initially non negativ e F urther evidence concerning the unph ysical nature of large amplitude oscillations in homogeneous shear o w can b e obtained from Rapid Distortion Theory RDT whic h w e w ould exp ect to b e an excellen t appro ximation to the Na vier Stok es equations for homogeneous shear o w when S K see Lee Kim and Moin In Figure the prediction of the FL T mo del for the time ev olution of is compared with the RDT solution for the initial conditions S K b b where b for i j These initial conditions corresp ond to an axisymme tric homoge ij neous turbulence for whic h w e w ere able to compute an energy sp ectrum tensor an input that is needed as an initial condition for RDT It is clear from the results in Figure that the FL T mo del is predicting spurious oscillations the same is true of the Shih Lumley mo del whic h is not sho wn These spurious oscillations app ear to arise from the in tro duction of higher degree nonlinearities in b within the rapid pressure strain mo dels see App endix B ij It m ust b e remem b ered that the rapid pressure strain correlation from its de nition is a lin e ar functional of the energy sp ectrum tensor The IP mo del whic h unlik e the Shih Lumley and FL T mo dels is consisten t with this linear prop ert y do es not exp erience unph ysical oscillations Evidence is b eginning to accum ulate concerning the coun ter pro ductiv e e ect that higher degree nonlinearities ha v e on the p erformance of pressure strain mo dels Conclusions The results of a detailed study on the realizabilit y of second order closure mo dels has b een presen ted within the framew ork of homogeneous turbulence Sev eral in teresting and surprising conclusions w ere arriv ed at whic h can b e summarized as follo ws The Shih Lumley mo del is not a realizable mo del and in man y instances su ers more realizabilit y violations than the older and more widely used IP mo del of Launder and co w ork ers This lac k of realizabilit y b ecomes apparen t when the non analytic terms in the Shih Lumley mo del are sho wn for the initial conditions S K b b in homogeneous shear o w again b for i j The Shih Lumley mo del b ecomes ij unrealizable whereas for these same initial conditions the IP mo del again yields realizable results as sho wn in Figure b Other computations indicated that the Shih Lumley mo del can b e driv en unrealizable for virtually an y initial conditions that are near a t w o comp onen t state of turbulence results that are consisten t with the analysis presen ted in the previous section As men tioned earlier the IP mo del is not a fully realizable second order closure Ho w ev er the only w a y that the IP mo del can b e made to yield unrealizable results in homogeneous shear o w is for the initial pro duction to b e ne gative and of a su cien t magnitude This is easy to see once w e recognize that when a principal Reynolds stress v anishes the IP mo del yields see App endix B C P whic h b ecome negativ e only if P C this then yields whic h leads to realizabilit y violations In Figure a the tra jectories in the phase space I I I I I obtained from the IP mo del are sho wn for the initial conditions S K b b b Since b is p ositiv e the initial pro duction is negativ e and the IP mo del b ecomes unre alizable On the other hand the FL T mo del whic h is a nonlinear extension of the IP mo del that w as form ulated to satisfy realizabilit y constrain ts yields realizable results for these initial conditions as sho wn in Figure b Although it is realizable the FL T mo del has problems with large amplitude oscillations lik e those of the Shih Lumley mo del This is illustrated in Figures a b where the predictions of the FL T mo del for F and b are compared with results obtained from the IP mo del The IP mo del is only unrealizable for a relativ ely short transien t i e for S t Although the FL T mo del is realizable its solution is con taminated b y large amplitude oscillations un til S t In order to further illustrate the problem that nonlinear mo dels suc h as the Shih Lumley and FL T mo dels ha v e with large amplitude oscillations w e return to the near one comp onen t initial conditions F or this case the FL T mo del is realizable as demonstrated b y the phase space tra jectories sho wn in Figure Ho w ev er some in teresting conclusions can b e dra wn from a comparison of the ratio of pro duction to dissipation P predicted b y the The Lumley anisotrop y in v arian t map is sup erimp osed on this gure realizable turbulence lies within this curvilinear triangle where the origin corresp onds to isotropic turbulence p oin t A corresp onds to t w o comp onen t axisymmetri c turbulence and p oin t B corresp onds to one comp onen t turbulence see Lumley It is clear from Figure a that the Shih Lumley mo del b ecomes unrealizable since its solution exits the triangle The computations q w ere conducted b y setting F jF j in the rapid mo del this is the only w a y that their mo del is b oth single v alued and computable to an equilibrium state As alluded to earlier p if w e set F F their mo del has no solution after F passes through zero when solv ed n umerically with an y nite time step a negativ e v alue of F is ev en tually computed b efore the critical time where F v anishes is arriv ed at an o ccurrence that causes the program to terminate in an error The computed results w ere v alidated n umerically b y an exhaustiv e grid re nemen t study In con trast to these results the IP mo del of Launder and co w ork ers is fully realizable for this set of initial conditions as sho wn in Figure b The time ev olution of F predicted b y the Shih Lumley and IP mo dels is compared in Figure a where henceforth the dimensionless time t S t Tw o notew orth y conclusions can b e dra wn from these results a The Shih Lumley mo del is unrealizable F for the large elapsed time of S t and b the Shih Lumley mo del undergo es large amplitude oscillations un til S t a result that will b e sho wn later to b e unph ysical Similar conclusions can b e dra wn from Figure b for the time ev olution of the shear anisotrop y b The Shih Lumley mo del oscillates b et w een p ositiv e and negativ e v alues whic h app ears to b e highly unph ysical p ositiv e v alues of b corresp ond to ne gative turbulence pro duction One migh t b e tempted to argue that the initial conditions are extreme and therefore constitute an o v erly stringen t test of the Shih Lumley mo del Ho w ev er it should b e said at the outset that a mo del whic h claims to satisfy the strong form of realizabilit y m ust withstand suc h a test particularly since the older IP mo del whic h mak es no claim of b eing generally realizable is able to do so F urthermore ev en if w e relax the initial conditions somewhat to the alternativ e v alues S K b b the Shih Lumley mo del still predicts unrealizable results as sho wn in Figure a The mo del remains ill b eha v ed yielding large amplitude oscillations for the time ev olutions of F and b as sho wn in Figures b c W e also conducted a v ariet y of calculations for initial conditions that w ere near the cen ter of the t w o comp onen t line of the Lumley anisotrop y in v arian t map In Figure a the tra jectories in the phase space I I I I I predicted b y Corrsin T a v oularis and Karnik and Rogers Moin and Reynolds In these exp erimen ts an initially isotropic turbulence ev olv es after it is sub jected to a uniform shear rate S Ho w ev er in order to pro vide a stringen t test of realizabilit y w e will consider initial conditions that are anisotropic and close to a one or t w o comp onen t state of turbulence where F the existing ph ysical and n umerical exp erimen ts as men tioned ab o v e ha v e concen trated on isotropic initial conditions where F F urthermore w e will consider large initial v alues of the shear parameter S K whic h can mak e a mo del more prone to exp erience realizabilit y violations The computations of homogeneous shear o w to b e presen ted consist of n umerical solu tions of the nonlinear ordinary di eren tial equations and sub ject to the constan t mean v elo cit y gradien t tensor v i S i j x j and the initial conditions S K S K b b ij ij at time t Three mo dels will b e considered for C and C in Eqs and the ij Shih Lumley SL mo del the F u Launder and Tselepidakis FL T mo del and the IP mo del whic h is a simpli ed form of the Launder Reece and Ro di mo del that has b een used in a v ariet y of applications starting with Gibson and Launder The detailed form of these mo dels is pro vided in App endix B Time accurate solutions w ere computed using a fourth order accurate Runge Kutta n umerical in tegration sc heme As in all existing second order closures the mo dels predict that b and S K ev en tually ac hiev e equilibrium ij v alues that are indep enden t of the initial conditions these constitute the xed p oin ts of the nonlinear di eren tial equations and Eac h of the mo dels yield realizable xed p oin ts for homogeneous shear o w A comparison of the equilibrium predictions of eac h of these three mo dels with ph ysical and n umerical exp erimen ts can b e found in Sp eziale Gatski and Mac Giolla Mh uiris and Sp eziale Gatski and Sark ar First w e will presen t computed results for the initial conditions S K b b giv en that b for i j here and in the other computations to follo w the corre ij sp onding initial condition for b can b e obtained from the traceless constrain t b This ii corresp onds to a strong uniform shear applied to an initially anisotropic turbulence that is close to a one comp onen t state the reader should remem b er that if b b then Figure a sho ws the computed tra jectories of the Shih Lumley mo del in the phase space I I I I I corresp onding to these initial conditions for homogeneous shear o w b e comp elling W eak realizabilit y only precludes an initially three comp onen t homogeneous turbulence from ac hieving a one or t w o comp onen t state in nite time it renders no constrain t on inhomogeneous turbulen t o ws suc h as those whic h o ccur near a solid b oundary The more serious criticism of w eak realizabilit y is that is inconsisten t with the Na vier Stok es equations As pro v en b y Sc h umann when a principal Reynolds stress comp onen t v anishes w e m ust ha v e This can b e easily seen from the asso ciated Sc h w arz inequalit y u u u u F rom it is clear that v anishes when v anishes Hence w e prop ose an al ternativ e form of w eak realizabilit y When a principal Reynolds stress v anishes w e require that ho w ev er when is in a neigh b orho o d of zero w e then enforce the constrain t that The latter condition guaran tees that an initially three comp onen t turbulence nev er ac hiev es a one or t w o comp onen t state ho w ev er it allo ws mo del predictions to come arbitrarily close to the b oundaries of realizable turbulence unlik e the form ulation of P op e This alternativ e form of w eak realizabilit y migh t b e satis ed as follo ws when is arbitrarily close to zero enforce the constrain ts S a C F R b O F with b a and C In traditional slo w pressure strain mo dels corresp onds to the conditions a C O F C C Here the exp onen ts a and b are completely arbitrary for simplici t y w e ha v e absorb ed D ij S in to In terestingly enough the mo del of F u Launder and Tselepidakis see ij App endix B satis es this alternativ e form of w eak realizabilit y with the exp onen t a and b In the next section w e will demonstrate computationally that this mo del is realizable i e it nev er yields negativ e comp onen t energies Illustrativ e Computations The theoretical p oin ts discussed in the previous section will no w b e demonstrated com putationally for homogeneous shear o w The test case of homogeneous shear o w is selected since it constitutes one of the simplest and most imp ortan t b enc hmark turbulen t o ws that has b een do cumen ted extensiv ely b y ph ysical and n umerical exp erimen ts T a v oularis and W e th us conclude that it app e ars to b e imp ossible to identic al ly satisfy the str ong form of r e alizability in the curr ent gener ation of se c ond or der closur e mo dels The only w a y to unequiv o cally guaran tee realizabilit y in the curren t v ersion of second order closures is to a v oid access to one or t w o comp onen t states of turbulence in the homogeneous limit The W eak F orm of Realizabilit y W e will no w consider the w eak form of realizabilit y where one or t w o comp onen t states are inaccessible in nite time As rst presen ted b y P op e w eak realizabilit y is satis ed if when a principal Reynolds stress v anishes This condition ensures that an initially three comp onen t turbulence nev er ac hiev es a t w o comp onen t state Realizabilit y is guaran teed without the need to imp ose a second deriv ativ e constrain t Ha w orth and P op e deriv ed a second order closure based on a Langevin equation W eak realizabilit y is satis ed therein as follo ws When a principal Reynolds stress v anishes R S In the Ha w orth and P op e mo del so it follo ws that ensures D ij the satisfaction of the w eak realizabilit y constrain t In that mo del as in virtually ev ery v ersion of the curren t generation of second order closures the slo w pressure strain correlation is mo deled as S C b C b b b b ij ik k j k k ij ij where the co e cien ts C and C can b e functions of the in v arian ts I I and I I I as w ell as the turbulence Reynolds n um b er Since b when the constrain t can b e satis ed when a principal Reynolds stress comp onen t v anishes pro vided that see Sark ar and Sp eziale C C C Hence an y slo w pressure strain mo del of form when com bined with a rapid pressure strain mo del that v anishes in the t w o comp onen t limit will b e realizable Lumley and co w ork ers ha v e criticized w eak realizabilit y on the grounds that one and t w o comp onen t states are made inaccessible they often cite the t w o comp onen t turbulence that o ccurs near a solid b oundary as a coun ter example W e do not consider this criticism to it follo ws that tr X tr g where and tr In all existing second order closure mo dels f is tak en to b e of the form ij f f S ij ij where relativ e to the xed co ordinate system x the comp onen ts of S and are giv en b y i v v v v i j i j S ij ij x x x x j i j i Here w e are considering homogeneous turbulen t o ws where S and are constan t tensors ij ij Ho w ev er while S and are zero the same is not true for S and whic h are non zero ij ij and dep end on due to the rotation of the principal axes Hence f dep ends explicitly on with a functional form determined b y and the homogeneous turbulence under consideration In order to isolate the terms arising from the rotation of the principal axes w e wrote in terms of g since f f g f f f f after and are implem e n ted It is clear from that g do es not dep end explicitly on this stands in con trast to f whic h dep ends on S and hence on as a result of The o diagonal comp onen ts of giv e f f f Hence can b ecome singular when a principal comp onen t of the Reynolds stress tensor sa y v anishes this will happ en when or also v anishes the one comp onen t limit and when the axisymmetri c t w o comp onen t limit A t these t w o critical p oin ts whic h constitute the end p oin ts of the t w o comp onen t line of the Lumley anisotrop y in v arian t map the second deriv ativ e can b ecome singular according to and This mak es it imp ossible to satisfy the crucial constrain t made single value d as r e quir e d on physic al gr ounds it fails to satisfy the crucial p ositive se c ond derivative c ondition a fatal aw that c an le ad to r e alizability violations In the next section illustrativ e computations of homogeneous shear o w will b e presen ted whic h de nitiv ely demonstrate that the Shih Lumley mo del is not realizable R otations of the Princip al Axes The use of the non analytic term F is not a viable means for ensuring realizabilit y as sho wn ab o v e The question remains as to whether there exist alternativ e mathematical forms that can iden tically satisfy the strong form of realizabilit y It will no w b e sho wn that the cen trifugal acceleration generated b y rotations of the principal axes of the Reynolds stress tensor can mak e singular at t w o of the most extreme limits of realizable turbulence in an y v ersion of the presen t generation of second order closures If is singular realizabilit y cannot b e guaran teed F or example consider the di eren tial equation F F Eq has the exact solution F F t whic h b ecomes negativ e and violates realizabilit y It is a simple matter with Eq to sho w that when F F and F Hence a singular second deriv ativ e ev en if it is p ositiv e can b e fatal with resp ect to realizabilit y By di eren tiating w e obtain the equation f F rom App endix A it follo ws that the comp onen t form of relativ e to the principal axes is giv en b y e e e e g where g f w e write this equation in terms of g since unlik e f it is free of an y explicit dep endence on Since relativ e to the principal axes w e ha v e and Ho w ev er there is a problem for t w e ha v e F whereas for t w e ha v e F as a result of Hence it is clear that the solutions of are remaining p p realizable b y virtue of F shifting branc hes b et w een F and F It is unacceptable for a turbulence mo del to ha v e m ultiple v alued functions when calculating a complex turbulen t p p o w ho w do w e kno w when to tak e F equal to F or F There is no ph ysically based selection rule The di eren tial equations corresp onding to the t w o branc hes of F are p F F and p F F Eq has no solution for t the solutions to and for t are p illustrated with the solid lines in Figure Shih and Lumley tacitly tak e F F if p they w ere to tak e F F then t w o comp onen t states w ould not b e accessible when C furthermore their mo del then predicts equilibrium v alues of the normal Reynolds stress anisotropies that are of the wrong sign Hence the Shih Lumley mo del actually b eha v es lik e the generic di eren tial equation in the vicinit y of F for C whic h has no solution when t A di eren tial equation lik e that yields an unde ned F is tec hnically unr e alizable since w e m ust ha v e F in a realizable turbulence The fact that there is a realizabilit y problem with can more easily b e seen in an alternativ e w a y If had realizable solutions for all times where F then w e should q p b e able to replace F in with the jF j The stable solution to the di eren tial equation q F jF j is illustrated in Figure and it is decidedly unrealizable F as t although formally has the xed p oin t F it is unstable The results displa y ed in Figure w ere obtained b y a Runge Kutta n umerical in tegration It can b e sho wn that the analytical form of the stable solution to is giv en b y q F F t H t where H is the Hea viside function F rom it follo ws that F is discon tin uous at the critical time t when F v anishes the one sided second deriv ativ es are F and F when F F or the nonlinear di eren tial equation F whereas F do es not exist at t where F In either case F is unde ned when F and hence the crucial second deriv ativ e constrain t is not satis ed This leads us to the follo wing imp ortan t conclusion When the non analytic terms in the Shih Lumley mo del ar e true for F see Figure A turbulence that b ecomes unrealizable b y passing through a one comp onen t state can corresp ond to F F or example consider a rst order T a ylor expansion for b in the neigh b orho o d of a one comp onen t turbulence where ij t B C B C B C B C b t ij B C B C A t Here and are constan ts and t is a short elapsed time after a one comp onen t state is ac hiev ed When either or is greater than zero the turbulence b ecomes unrealizable since b for realizable turbulence It is a simple matter to sho w from Eq ii that if and then F furthermore when and then F In either case the turbulence b ecomes unrealizable with F This leads us to our rst p ertinen t conclusion The metho dolo gy of Shih and Lumley is fundamental ly inc ap able of guar ante eing r e alizability for turbulent ows that ar e ne ar a one c omp onent state While this is not the ma jor de ciency with the Shih Lumley approac h it is still of consequence since turbulence that is near a one comp onen t state is asymptotically approac hed in certain geoph ysical o ws with strong strati cation see Zeman and Lumley A mo del that claims to b e fully realizable m ust accommo date suc h a limit The Centr al Pr oblem of Non A nalyticity The ma jor de ciency with the Shih Lumley mo del lies in its use of the non analytic R function F as a means to satisfy realizabilit y If the dimensionless time t C dt is in tro duced in to it follo ws that its exact solution can b e written in the form F F t p p p Since F F where F denotes the p ositiv e v alue of the square ro ot i e F jF j it follo ws that there are t w o principal branc hes to the solution q F F t and q F F t whic h are illustrated graphically in Figure for an initial condition of F If starting from an y F w e w an t to pass through a t w o comp onen t state of turbulence where F and then turn bac k up w e m ust pic k the second branc h of this solution giv en b y T ensorially in v arian t forms that b eha v e lik e near where or w ere obtained b y Shih and Lumley b y the in tro duction of the in v arian t function F I I I I I where I I and I I I are resp ectiv ely the second and third in v arian ts of the anisotrop y tensor b see App endix B and Lumley It is a simple matter to sho w that ij F K in terms of the principal Reynolds stresses F or an y realizable turbulence w e m ust ha v e F see Lumley This prompted Shih and Lumley to suggest the tensorially in v arian t form F in the limit as and hence F go es to zero The full tensorial asymptotic form of the Shih Lumley mo del near is giv en b y v K P F x where P v x is the turbulence pro duction and and are mo del constan ts ij i j that are p ositiv e Since the co e cien t that m ultiplies F in can b e negativ e the Shih Lumley mo del allo ws access to one and t w o comp onen t states of turbulence The One Comp onent Limit The logic used b y Shih and Lumley app ears on the surface to b e sound They argued that guaran tees that when v anishes it follo ws that v anishes with a set of conditions whic h should ensure that nev er b ecomes negativ e as discussed in the previous section While this line of reasoning app ears to b e correct at rst glance a deep er analysis unco v ers a fundamen tal problem By making use of it is clear that for and F close to zero can b e rewritten in the form F C F where in the neigh b orho o d of w e can treat the co e cien t C as a constan t On the basis of it follo ws that when F F and F C whic h is p ositiv e Ho w ev er as w e will so on see it w ould b e a mistak e to conclude that guaran tees realizabilit y due to a v ariet y of di culties Ev en though can yield solutions where F for all times there is a subtle problem While F corresp onds to unrealizable turbulence the con v erse is not see Sc h umann and Lumley This constrain t is t ypically satis ed b y guaran teeing that when v anishes S D R S R where and are resp ectiv ely the slo w and rapid parts of the pressure strain correla S R tion here cf Lumley While the realizabilit y constrain ts are a rigorous consequence of the Na vier Stok es equations in and of themselv e s they are neither necessary nor su cien t to guaran tee realizabilit y As sho wn b y P op e realiz abilit y can b e satis ed if is replaced with the w eak er constrain t F urthermore ev en if the constrain t is satis ed when v anishes an added second deriv ativ e condition m ust b e met for full realizabilit y namely w e must ha v e If then the rst non v anishing deriv ativ e of m ust b e p ositiv e and b ounded It is crucial that the non negativ e second deriv ativ e constrain t b e prop erly satis ed to guaran tee the realizabilit y of second order closures that allo w one or t w o comp onen t states of turbulence to b e accessible in nite time i e is a critical constrain t for the satisfaction of the str ong form of r e alizability This constrain t has not b een prop erly analyzed in previous applications of realizabilit y to second order closure mo deling as w e will sho w in the next section Analysis of Existing Second Order Closures In this section the strong form of realizabilit y will b e critically assessed based on an analysis of the mo del prop osed b y Shih and Lumley A new statemen t of the w eak form of realizabilit y will also b e pro vided along with an example of a mo del the F u Launder and Tselep edakis mo del that satis es this constrain t and is realizable The Strong F orm of Realizabilit y In the Shih Lumley mo del see App endix B an attempt is made to satisfy the second deriv ativ e constrain t b y the construction of a rapid pressure strain mo del that b eha v es asymptotically as near t w o comp onen t states of turbulence where Here it is understo o d that the prop ortionalit y factor m ust b e ne gative in order to allo w access to t w o comp onen t states v ectors e e e e the comp onen ts of are giv en b y Ho w ev er relativ e to the i principal axes whic h ha v e the base v ectors the comp onen t form of is more complex since the basis is rotating in time F or an y symmetri c second rank tensor T it can b e sho wn that see App endix A T T e T e T where e is the p erm utation tensor and t is the angular v elo cit y at whic h the principal axes are rotating Relativ e to the principal axes tak es the form f e e Ho w ev er the Reynolds stress tensor is diagonal relativ e to the principal axes where for are the principal Reynolds stresses and the Einstein summation con v en tion is susp ended for indices that lie within paren theses F rom it is no w clear that f e e and th us w e ha v e f b y setting since e from the de nition of the p erm utation tensor It has th us b een sho wn that consisten t with the earlier pro of presen ted b y Lumley rotations of the principal axes of the Reynolds stress tensor ha v e no e ect on the form ulation of the rst deriv ativ e constrain t As w e will demonstrate later suc h rotations ha v e an imp ortan t e ect on the form ulation of the second deriv ativ e constrain t Sc h umann sho w ed that when it follo ws that the correlations P as a rigorous consequence of their de nitions and the Sc h w arz inequalit y Since f P it follo ws that f v anishes when This leads us to the long established realizabilit y constrain t When it fol lows that are resp ectiv ely the pressure strain correlation and the dissipation rate tensor The dissi pation rate tensor can b e split in to isotropic and deviatoric parts resp ectiv ely as follo ws ij ij D ij where u u i i x x j j is the scalar dissipation rate W riting ij ij ij ij with it follo ws from that closure is ac hiev ed once mo dels for and ij ij D ij ij are pro vided The curren t generation of second order closures are based on mo dels for ij and that reduce to the general form cf Reynolds and Sp eziale v k A b K M b ij ij ij k x v i C C ij K x K j for homogeneous turbulen t o ws In K ij ij K b ii ij K are resp ectiv ely the turbulen t kinetic energy and anisotrop y tensor the co e cien ts C and C are t ypically tak en to b e either constan ts or functions of the turbulence Reynolds n um b er Re K and p ossibly the dimensionless in v arian ts of v x t i j As rst p oin ted out b y Sc h umann and Lumley it is easier to examine the question of realizabilit y in a co ordinate system aligned with the principal axes of the Reynolds stress tensor Ho w ev er considerable care m ust b e tak en in suc h an analysis since the principal axes of the Reynolds stress tensor can rotate in a time dep enden t manner for temp orally ev olving homogeneous turbulen t o ws In co ordinate free notation can b e written as a dynamical system f where f P I giv en that I is the unit tensor and P is the pro duction tensor whose comp onen ts are pro vided b y the rst t w o terms on the righ t hand side of In a xed co ordinate system with base via a sto c hastic analysis to guaran tee realizabilit y in suc h extreme cases with b etter b eha v ed predictions These issues will b e discussed in detail in the sections to follo w and illustrativ e calculations of homogeneous shear o w will b e pro vided Realizabilit y Constrain ts for Second Order Closures W e will consider incompressible turbulen t o ws go v erned b y the Na vier Stok es and con tin uit y equations v v P i i v r v j i t x x j i v i x i where v is the v elo cit y v ector P is the kinematic pressure and is the kinematic viscosit y i of the uid As in all studies of Reynolds stress mo deling the v elo cit y and pressure are decomp osed in to mean and uctuating parts as follo ws v v u P P p i i i where an o v erbar represen ts an ensem ble mean The Reynolds a v eraged Na vier Stok es and con tin uit y equations tak e the form v v P i i ij v r v j i t x x x j i j v i x i where u u is the Reynolds stress tensor F rom its de nition it is clear that has non ij i j ij negativ e eigen v alues a prop ert y that realizabilit y constrain ts seek to preserv e in Reynolds stress mo dels In order to ac hiev e closure m ust b e supplemen ted with a Reynolds stress mo del that ties to the global history of the mean v elo cit y eld in a ph ysically reasonable fashion ij W e will analyze second order closure mo dels that are based on the Reynolds stress transp ort equation whic h for homogeneous turbulence simpli es to the form cf Hinze v v j i ij ik j k ij ij x x k k where u u u u i j i j p ij ij x x x x j i k k kno wn as the we ak form of r e alizability P op e only required that when a principal Reynolds stress comp onen t v anishes its time deriv ativ e b e p ositiv e This do es guaran tee realizabilit y in that non negativ e energy comp onen ts cannot o ccur when this constrain t is satis ed It also has the adv an tage of eliminating the need to enforce the p ositiv e second time deriv ativ e constrain t since a mo del that prop erly satis es the w eak form of realizabilit y can nev er access one or t w o comp onen t states of turbulence in nite time Lumley and co w ork ers criticized the w eak form of realizabilit y on the grounds that states of t w o comp onen t turbulence whic h can o ccur in practical turbulen t o ws near a solid b oundary w ere inaccessible Nev ertheless Ha w orth and P op e and P op e deriv ed second order closures for homogeneous turbulence from a Langevin equation that satis ed this w eak form of realizabilit y and hence guaran teed p ositiv e comp onen t energies While Langevin equations had b een used to pro v e realizabilit y of the DIA and EDQNM t w o p oin t closures see Kraic hnan and Orszag P op e w as the rst to bring this sto c hastic analysis in to the realm of second order closure mo deling The purp ose of the presen t pap er is to clarify the issue of realizabilit y in second order closure mo deling and to discuss alternativ e means of ensuring realizable solutions In regard to the former p oin t there are a v ariet y of confusing and con icting claims in the literature that need to b e clari ed a task that can b e accomplished within the con text of homogeneous turbulence It will b e pro v en mathematically and demonstrated computationally that the Shih Lumley mo del yields unrealizable solutions The lac k of realizabilit y arises from the failure to satisfy the necessary p ositiv e second time deriv ativ e constrain t when a principal Reynolds stress v anishes a crucial condition that m ust b e satis ed b y mo dels that allo w access to one or t w o comp onen t states of turbulence This problem only b ecomes apparen t when the non analytic terms in the Shih Lumley mo del are made single v alued as required for ph ysical consistency a turbulence mo del cannot con tain functions that are m ultiple v alued and giv e rise to non unique solutions It will furthermore b e sho wn that the cen trifugal acceleration generated b y rotations of the principal axes of the Reynolds stress tensor can mak e second and higher order time deriv ativ es singular at the most extreme limits of t w o comp onen t turbulence This is a heretofore neglected e ect that app ears to mak e an y v ersion of the presen t generation of second order closures incapable of iden tically satisfying the strong form of realizabilit y F orm ulations of the w eak form of realizabilit y whic h do giv e rise to realizable mo dels are examined critically and a more ph ysically consisten t statemen t of this constrain t is pro vided Ho w ev er mo dels that satisfy the w eak as w ell as the strong form of realizabilit y can b e ill b eha v ed near one and t w o comp onen t states of turbulence due to the unnecessary in tro duction of higher degree nonlinearities to satisfy realizabilit y In a related pap er Durbin and Sp eziale it is sho wn ho w linear mo dels can b e mo di ed In tro duction Second order closure mo dels ha v e b een an activ e area of researc h in turbulence mo del ing for the past few decades Since second order closures are based on the Reynolds stress transp ort equation whic h accoun ts for b oth history and nonlo cal e ects these mo dels in principle allo w for the description of more turbulence ph ysics than lo w er lev el closures Sc h umann w as the rst to systematically address the issue of realizabilit y in second order closure mo deling The constrain t of realizabilit y requires that a Reynolds stress mo del yield non negativ e comp onen t energies in all turbulen t o ws with the Sc h w arz inequalit y satis ed for eac h o diagonal comp onen t of the Reynolds stress tensor Sc h umann sho w ed that realizabilit y is satis ed iden tically b y a mo del if starting from an y realizable initial con ditions it predicts a Reynolds stress tensor with non negativ e eigen v alues for all later times He also pro vided a v ariet y of necessary conditions for the satisfaction of realizabilit y and brie y outlined a prop osed metho d for making unrealizable second order closures realizable This issue w as of in terest since it had long b een kno wn that unrealizable second order clo sure mo dels can lead to n umerical instabilities The ad ho c n umerical tec hnique of clipping whereb y when a negativ e comp onen t energy is computed it is arbitrarily set to zero w as in tro duced to alleviate just suc h a problem see Deardor Lumley w as the rst to adv o cate the systematic use of realizabilit y con strain ts in the form ulation and calibration of second order closure mo dels He clari ed the constrain ts that a second order closure should satisfy in order to b e consisten t with the str ong form of r e alizability When a principal Reynolds stress comp onen t v anishes its time rate m ust also v anish and its second deriv ativ e m ust b e p ositiv e Ho w ev er Lumley made a signi can t departure from Sc h umann in so far as he suggested that realizabilit y could serv e as a p o w erful new constrain t in determining the allo w able mathematical form of Reynolds stress mo dels Lumley also in tro duced the constrain t of join t realizabil it y in to second order closure mo deling whereb y the Sc h w arz inequalit y is imp osed on scalar uxes A few y ears later Shih and Lumley dev elop ed a rapid pressure strain mo del based on the implem en tation of in v arian t tensor theory and realizabilit y constrain ts alone They com bined this new rapid mo del after some subsequen t mo di cations w ere made with the slo w pressure strain and isotropic dissipation rate mo dels that Lumley had de v elop ed earlier The resulting second order closure has b een commonly referred to as the Shih Lumley mo del in the literature Shih and Lumley who claimed that their mo del w as the rst generally realizable second order closure subsequen tly rep orted a few applications to turbulen t shear o ws see Shih and Lumley Ho w ev er they did not rep ort an y tests of their mo del demonstrating whether it did indeed guaran tee realizable solutions P op e departed from the approac h of Lumley in prop osing what has come to b e NEW RESUL TS ON THE REALIZABILITY OF REYNOLDS STRESS TURBULENCE CLOSURES Charles G Sp eziale Aerospace Mec hanical Engineering Departmen t Boston Univ ersit y Boston MA Ridha Abid High T ec hnology Corp oration NASA Langley Researc h Cen ter Hampton V A P aul A Durbin Cen ter for T urbulence Researc h Stanford Univ ersit y Stanford CA ABSTRA CT The realizabilit y of Reynolds stress mo dels in homogeneous turbulence is critically as sessed from a theoretical standp oin t It is pro v en that a w ell kno wn second order closure form ulated b y Shih and Lumley using the strong realizabilit y constrain ts of Sc h umann is in fact not a realizable mo del The problem arises from the failure to prop erly satisfy the nec essary p ositiv e second time deriv ativ e constrain t when a principal Reynolds stress v anishes a fatal a w that b ecomes apparen t when the non analytic terms in their mo del are made single v alued as required on ph ysical grounds It is furthermore sho wn that the cen trifugal acceleration generated b y rotations of the principal axes of the Reynolds stress tensor can mak e the second deriv ativ e singular at the most extreme limits of realizable turbulence This previously o v erlo ok ed e ect app ears to mak e it imp ossible to iden tically satisfy the strong form of realizabilit y in an y v ersion of the presen t generation of second order closures On the other hand mo dels prop erly form ulated to satisfy the w eak form of realizabilit y wherein states of one or t w o comp onen t turbulence are not accessible in nite time are found to b e realizable Ho w ev er unlik e the simpler and more commonly used second order closures these mo dels can b e ill b eha v ed near the extreme limits of realizable turbulence due to the w a y that higher degree nonlinearities are often unnecessarily in tro duced to satisfy realiz abilit y Illustrativ e computations of homogeneous shear o ws are presen ted to demonstrate these p oin ts whic h can ha v e imp ortan t implications for turbulence mo deling This researc h w as supp orted b y the National Aeronautics and Space Administration under NASA Con tract No NAS while the rst author w as in residence at the Institute for Computer Applications in Science and Engineering ICASE NASA Langley Researc h Cen ter Hampton V A i